Independent insurance. Arizona roots.
Se habla españolCall: (602) 910-6505Text: (602) 362-5089
Mota Ins Agency
Insurance Resources / Blog

AUTO INSURANCE

Uninsured vs. Underinsured Motorist Coverage: What Arizona Drivers Should Know

By Arnie Mota ·

Uninsured motorist coverage and underinsured motorist coverage address different injury risks. Uninsured motorist coverage, often called UM, can help when the responsible driver lacks qualifying liability insurance. Underinsured motorist coverage, or UIM, can help when applicable liability insurance is insufficient for the injured person’s covered damages. In Arizona, these are separate coverages for bodily injury or death, subject to the policy and state law.

For families driving across Phoenix and the West Valley, a useful insurance review asks two questions: “What protection do I have if I injure someone?” and “What protection do I have if someone injures me?” Your auto policy can answer those questions through different coverage sections.

What is the difference between UM and UIM?

Think of two possible accidents. In the first, another driver causes an injury accident and has no liability insurance. That raises a UM question. In the second, the driver has insurance, but the available bodily injury limits fall short of the injured person’s damages. That raises a UIM question.

Neither situation guarantees payment. Fault, who qualifies as an insured, the damages, policy limits, and other terms still matter. Arizona law expressly treats UM and UIM as separate coverages applying to different accident situations.

Source: Arizona Revised Statutes § 20-259.01.

Does Arizona require me to buy these coverages?

UM and UIM are optional purchases for Arizona personal auto customers, but insurers must offer them under the state’s rules. Do not assume you have either coverage because you carry liability insurance or because someone described your policy as “full coverage.”

Look at your declarations page for each coverage and its selected limit. If you previously declined coverage or selected lower limits, ask your agent to explain what is currently in force and quote alternatives. An old selection may no longer match your household’s needs.

Sources: Arizona’s offer and selection requirements; Arizona DIFI automobile insurance guide.

What kinds of injury costs might be covered?

Depending on the claim and policy, UM or UIM can address covered damages such as medical expenses, lost income, and pain and suffering. Payment is limited by the coverage purchased and the applicable claim requirements.

This is one reason to discuss the coverage even if you have health insurance. A health plan and an auto injury claim serve different purposes. Ask how your health benefits, income protection, medical payments coverage, and UM/UIM fit together. Avoid assuming that one policy handles every financial consequence of an accident.

Source: Educational explanation of uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage.

Will UM or UIM pay to repair my car?

Do not rely on Arizona UM/UIM bodily injury coverage for vehicle repairs. Review collision coverage separately. Collision generally addresses covered damage to your vehicle from a collision, subject to its deductible and policy terms.

A single accident can therefore involve separate questions about your injuries, your car, and temporary transportation. Ask your agent to identify the relevant coverage for each. National articles sometimes discuss uninsured motorist property damage available in other states; those descriptions do not establish that it is included in your Arizona policy.

Sources: Arizona UM/UIM definitions; NAIC Consumer’s Guide to Auto Insurance.

How much coverage should I consider?

There is no single limit that fits every household. Start by asking your agent for a side-by-side comparison of your current coverage and available alternatives. Compare the actual limits and premium difference rather than deciding from a general rule of thumb.

Use these questions to guide the conversation:

  • What UM and UIM limits are on my policy today?
  • Are the limits shown per person, per accident, or another way?
  • Who qualifies as an insured under each coverage?
  • How do my household drivers and regular passengers affect the review?
  • What would higher limits cost, and what selections are available?
  • What other policies should we review for gaps or overlapping benefits?

Bring your declarations page to the appointment and request the comparison in writing. That makes it easier to discuss the options with a spouse or another household decision-maker without trying to remember the details later.

What should I check when comparing auto quotes?

Match coverage choices before judging the prices. Two quotes may have similar liability limits while one omits UM or UIM, uses lower injury limits, or changes collision deductibles. A lower total premium alone does not explain the difference.

The NAIC recommends comparing matching coverages and limits and asking for revised estimates when the selections differ. Keep an eye on medical payments, rental reimbursement, and other options too.

Source: NAIC guidance on comparing auto insurance quotes.

Frequently asked questions

Does having both UM and UIM mean both pay for every accident?

No. They apply to different circumstances. Ask which coverage applies to the facts of a particular claim rather than adding the two limits together.

Can passengers be protected?

They may be. Arizona DIFI describes UM/UIM protection for injuries to you or passengers. The actual policy determines who qualifies, and the available limits apply to the claim.

Does paying off my car change whether injury coverage matters?

A loan balance is a different consideration from injuries to people. When a vehicle is paid off, review each coverage on its own merits instead of removing several options simply because the lender no longer requires insurance on the car.

Can I add coverage after an accident?

A later purchase does not create retroactive coverage for an accident that already happened. Ask your agent to confirm when any requested change takes effect, and obtain confirmation before relying on it.

Get a clearer picture of your auto policy

Mota Ins Agency can help you review your current selections and compare available options. Explore our Arizona auto insurance page or request a coverage review or quote. Call (602) 910-6505 or email info@motainsagency.com.

This article provides general educational information. Coverage, eligibility, limits, exclusions, definitions, and claim requirements vary by insurer and policy and are subject to applicable law. The complete policy determines coverage. Requesting a quote does not bind or change insurance.

View all articles
Call your local agent